Home/r/IndieDev/#8032
1482

Ive been making this game for years, it’s made no money, this is what someone decides to comment?

r/IndieDev
8/15/2025

Content Summary

The post discusses an indie game developer's frustration with receiving negative and unconstructive comments online. The developer has been working on a game since 2017 but has not seen financial success. They are confused by the presence of haters in the indie game community and seek support from others. The comments section is filled with discussions about dealing with online negativity, the importance of ignoring trolls, and the value of constructive feedback. Many users encourage the developer to focus on their work and not let negative comments affect their motivation.

Opinion Analysis

Mainstream opinions in the discussion emphasize the importance of ignoring negative comments and focusing on constructive feedback. Many users believe that online negativity is inevitable and that developers should not take it personally. Some argue that people who leave negative comments often lack the skills or dedication to create anything themselves. There is also a strong sentiment that the indie game community is supportive and that developers should not let isolated negative comments deter them from their goals. However, some users express frustration with the prevalence of online hate and the difficulty of filtering out harmful comments. Overall, the discussion highlights the challenges of creating and sharing creative work in an environment where negative feedback is common.

SAAS TOOLS

SaaSURLCategoryFeatures/Notes
N/AN/AN/AN/A

USER NEEDS

Pain Points:

  • Dealing with negative and unconstructive criticism from online communities
  • Handling hate comments and trolling behavior
  • Building a thick skin to withstand online negativity
  • Balancing creative passion with the realities of game development
  • Overcoming self-doubt and maintaining motivation

Problems to Solve:

  • How to handle toxic online feedback without letting it affect creativity or mental health
  • How to maintain focus on creating quality games despite external negativity
  • How to build a supportive community around indie game development
  • How to manage expectations about the reception of a game

Potential Solutions:

  • Ignoring or blocking negative commenters
  • Focusing on constructive feedback from genuine users
  • Engaging with supportive communities and developers
  • Maintaining a positive mindset and not letting negativity define success

GROWTH FACTORS

Effective Strategies:

  • Building a supportive community around game development
  • Focusing on creating quality content that resonates with players
  • Leveraging positive feedback and user engagement
  • Embracing the journey of game development, even with challenges

Marketing & Acquisition:

  • Utilizing platforms like Reddit to share experiences and gain support
  • Engaging with other developers for encouragement and advice
  • Sharing game progress and updates to maintain interest

Monetization & Product:

  • Creating free-to-play games with optional monetization strategies
  • Considering alternative revenue models such as donations or Patreon
  • Balancing game design to ensure accessibility and enjoyment for all players

User Engagement:

  • Encouraging positive interactions within game communities
  • Responding to constructive feedback to improve the game
  • Building a loyal player base through consistent development and communication