52
Content Summary
A solo developer released their first multiplayer physics game 'Twisted Jam' after 14 months of unpaid work. Despite being a financial failure, the developer gained valuable experience. Key lessons include the importance of marketing before launch, challenges of multiplayer-only indie games (player dependency), and pricing difficulties. The developer plans to seek employment while continuing game development as a side activity, focusing on simpler projects. Comments highlight issues with game polish, pricing strategy ($10 being too high), and suggest post-launch improvements.
Opinion Analysis
Mainstream opinions:
- Releasing a complete game is a major achievement worth celebrating, even if it fails commercially.
- Multiplayer-only indie games face inherent challenges due to player dependency ('needs players to attract players').
- $10 pricing is too high for an unpolished multiplayer indie game; free-to-play or lower pricing is suggested.
- Marketing should begin before launch, with emphasis on building wishlists and followers.
Conflicting viewpoints:
- On marketing necessity: While OP and most commenters stress pre-launch marketing, u/diogo_dev_ argues that 'if the game is genuinely good, people will talk about it' (organic virality). However, others imply this is unrealistic for unknown indie devs.
- On failure timeline: Some question whether labeling the game a 'flop' after one week is premature (u/jonnyhawkwind, u/GatePorters), while OP considers it financially failed.
Debates:
- Pricing strategy: Significant discussion on how to price indie games, with suggestions ranging from competitor benchmarking (u/gabgames_48) to sophisticated 'sourcing' methods (u/jeango).
- Genre selection: Strong consensus that multiplayer FPS is a 'cursed' genre for indies (u/Idiberug citing HTMAG), though OP acknowledges this in hindsight.
SAAS TOOLS
| SaaS | URL | Category | Features/Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Steam | https://store.steampowered.com | Game Distribution | Platform for publishing and selling games |
USER NEEDS
Pain Points:
- Difficulty in marketing indie games effectively
- Challenges with multiplayer game adoption (player dependency)
- Pricing uncertainty for indie games
- Lack of polish/aesthetic affecting game appeal
- Financial pressure from unpaid development periods
Problems to Solve:
- How to attract initial players for multiplayer games
- Determining optimal pricing for indie games
- Improving game visuals and polish
- Building a following before launch
- Balancing game development with financial stability
Potential Solutions:
- Focus marketing efforts before launch (as suggested by OP)
- Create compelling trailers showcasing gameplay
- Lower price point or free-to-play model for multiplayer games
- Use reference games for pricing benchmarks
- Develop simpler game types initially
- Continuous updates and post-launch marketing
GROWTH FACTORS
Effective Strategies:
- Learning from failure as valuable experience
- Starting with simpler projects before tackling complex genres
- Continuous improvement through updates
Marketing & Acquisition:
- Pre-launch marketing is crucial (OP's key lesson)
- Building wishlists and followers before release
- Creating high-quality trailers for first impressions
- Pricing adjustments to attract initial users
Monetization & Product:
- Avoid premium pricing for multiplayer-only indie games
- Free-to-play or subscription models work better for multiplayer
- Reference competitor pricing using review-based metrics
- Focus on product polish and aesthetics
User Engagement:
- Community building through Discord/X (Twitter)
- Post-launch updates to retain players
- Participating in game jams for visibility