30
Everyone: "Do not scope creep!" - Me: "Let's add moving bushes!!!"
r/IndieDev
7/11/2025
Content Summary
The developer shares a feature (moving bushes) added to their game 'Engraving' despite concerns about scope creep. They explain that this polish enhances immersion, as lack of feedback made movement feel disconnected. The post promotes Steam wishlisting and offers to answer questions. Comments overwhelmingly support the decision, arguing it's polish not scope creep, and that such details make a product commercial-ready.
Opinion Analysis
Mainstream Opinion:
- Overwhelming consensus that adding moving bushes is polish, not scope creep, and essential for immersion and commercial viability.
- Users agree that such small details elevate the game from a prototype to a professional product.
Conflicting Views:
- No significant conflict; all comments support the developer's decision.
Other Perspectives:
- One user (u/OwO-animals) adds nuance: scope extension is acceptable if initial scope was severely limited, bringing development back to 'default' levels.
- Skyrim comparison is seen as a compliment, reinforcing the value of immersive details.
SAAS TOOLS
| SaaS | URL | Category | Features/Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Godot Engine | https://godotengine.org/ | Game Development Engine | Open-source game engine used for developing the game 'Engraving' |
USER NEEDS
Pain Points:
- Lack of feedback when moving through bushes in the game, leading to a disconnected feeling
Problems to Solve:
- Enhancing player immersion and interaction with game elements
Potential Solutions:
- Adding visual feedback like moving bushes to create a more immersive experience
GROWTH FACTORS
Effective Strategies:
- Focusing on polish and small immersive features to elevate the product
Marketing & Acquisition:
- Encouraging Steam wishlists to build anticipation and initial user base
- Engaging with community by answering questions
Monetization & Product:
- Prioritizing features that enhance immersion and polish for commercial viability
User Engagement:
- Actively responding to comments and feedback on social platforms like Reddit