Home/r/SaaS/2025-06-28/#3305
204

The MVP myth is destroying good products

r/SaaS
6/27/2025

SAAS TOOLS

SaaSURLCategoryFeatures/Notes
DropboxNot providedCloud StorageUsed as example: Created demo video instead of building full product for initial validation
TypeformNot providedSurvey ToolSuggested for structured surveys in discovery phase
LookbackNot providedUX ResearchSuggested for live user experience testing
Pulse for RedditNot providedSocial ListeningSuggested to surface unfiltered complaints

USER NEEDS

Pain Points:

  • Users bounce from incomplete MVPs that don't solve their core problem
  • Founders misinterpret 'viable' in MVP as 'barely functional' instead of 'complete value'
  • Lack of meaningful user feedback due to poor user retention
  • Technical debt accumulation from rushed MVPs
  • Competitors with more complete solutions gain market share

Problems to Solve:

  • How to define a truly viable MVP that delivers complete value
  • How to validate product ideas before full development
  • How to gather quality user feedback for iteration
  • How to balance speed with product completeness
  • How to identify core features that are deal-breakers

Potential Solutions:

  • Conduct thorough customer discovery through interviews (5-6 users recommended)
  • Build prototypes for validation before MVP development
  • Focus on solving one painful job completely rather than multiple partially
  • Adopt 'Simple, Lovable, Complete' (SLC) approach instead of traditional MVP
  • Use non-code MVPs like demo videos (Dropbox example) or landing pages
  • Implement concierge testing to identify core automation needs

GROWTH FACTORS

Effective Strategies:

  • Prioritize delivering complete value in initial product over speed to market
  • Build engaged user base through problem-solving products rather than chasing vanity metrics
  • Focus on narrow but complete feature scope for initial launch

Marketing & Acquisition:

  • Use waitlists and demo videos for pre-launch validation (Dropbox model)
  • Target early adopters through problem-focused interviews
  • Leverage landing pages to gather interest before product completion

Monetization & Product:

  • Ensure MVP is actually sellable/solves pain point sufficiently for users to pay
  • Avoid feature bloat by using MoSCoW method (Must-have/Should-have/Could-have/Won't-have)
  • Price based on delivered value rather than development cost
  • Technical foundation quality affects long-term scalability and iteration speed

User Engagement:

  • Build products users want to keep using to enable quality feedback loops
  • Use live UX testing tools (e.g. Lookback) during development
  • Create community through transparent development processes
  • Instrument products to track user activation rates (>50% after two sessions suggested as benchmark)